Etymotic ER2XR

The reviewer was initially skeptical of the Etymotic ER2XR but ended up loving them, praising their natural tonality, realistic timbre, and well-controlled bass and mids. He notes the treble rolls off early and the soundstage is intimate, but overall he highly recommends them for their exceptional sound quality, especially for tone and timbre, despite the deep-fit comfort issues some may have.

The reviewer compares the ER2-SE and ER2-XR, noting they share a similar design and core sound signature but differ in tuning. The XR model offers a more extended bass response, making it more engaging for general listening, while the SE is more neutral and suited for studio work. The reviewer appreciates both for their unique strengths.

The reviewer highly recommends the Etymotic ER2XR as the best IEM under $200, praising its exceptional bass quality, natural timbre, and vocal imaging, despite noting a deep-fit requirement and a slightly dark treble. They consider it a standout that punches well above its price, even competing with higher-priced models.

The reviewer finds the Etymotic ER2XR's stock ear tips extremely uncomfortable, so they recommend two alternative tips: Shure yellow foam tips and Final Audio E tips with an adapter. They rate the sound quality with these mods, noting the foam tips are more faithful to the original sound, while the Final Audio E tips add bass and warmth but alter vocals and treble. Overall, they conclude the ER2XR sounds great with these modifications, but the stock experience is painful.

The reviewer praises the Etymotic ER2XR for its accurate sound and overall solid performance, but notes that the stock ear tips are painful and uncomfortable. They strongly recommend replacing them with Final Audio ear tips, which, when used with the included red adapter, dramatically improve comfort and make the headphones much more enjoyable to wear.