Skip to content
HearWiki

ASTRO Gaming A50 Gen 5 vs Shure Srh440a: which should you buy?

On aggregated review scores the ASTRO Gaming A50 Gen 5 comes out ahead with a HearWiki score of 80. The full breakdown - sub-scores, specs and what reviewers actually said - is below.

Our pick: ASTRO Gaming A50 Gen 5 - Great overall at around $260.

Score breakdown

Each axis is a 0–10 blend of what reviewers scored, not a lab measurement.

ASTRO Gaming A50 Gen 5 leads on 4 of 6 measures.

  • ASTRO Gaming A50 Gen 5
  • Shure Srh440a
HearWiki score
80
67
Sound
8.2
7.0
Battery
7.1
-
Calls
9.2
-
Value
7.4
7.5
Price (USD)
$260
$110

Generation & platform

The scores rank quality. This is the other question: is the newer one actually newer technology, or the same platform in a new shell?

Same generation

The ASTRO Gaming A50 Gen 5 is 3 years newer, but it is the same generation of hardware: nothing in the radio, the codecs or the noise cancelling separates them. The platform is level; the newer hardware shows up in convenience features instead - the ASTRO Gaming A50 Gen 5 adds USB-C. For 3 years between them, that is a thin return - treat this as a restyle rather than a new platform.

  • A50 Gen 520253 yr newer
  • Srh440a2022
What differsA50 Gen 5Srh440a

Everyday features

USB-C
Yes
No

Specifications

A50 Gen 5Srh440a
Type
Over-Ear
Over-Ear
Price (USD)
$260
$110
HearWiki score
80
67
Released
2025
2022
Availability
Sold new
Discontinued
Driver
40 mm dynamic
40 mm dynamic
Driver type
dynamic
dynamic
Driver size
40 mm
40 mm
Drivers per side
1
1
Frequency response
20 Hz - 20 kHz
10 Hz - 22 kHz
Sound signature
-
neutral
Impedance
32 Ω
40 Ω
Sensitivity
-
97 dB/mW
Bluetooth
5.2
-
Codecs
SBC
-
Multipoint pairing
Yes
-
Latency
20 ms
-
Wireless range
12 m
-
Battery life
24 h
-
Full charge time
180 min
-
Quick charge
10 min → 2 h
-
Wireless charging
Yes
-
Active noise cancelling
No
No
ANC type
none
-
Transparency mode
No
-
Companion app
Yes
-
Custom EQ
Yes
-
Wear detection
No
-
Controls
buttons
-
Weight
363 g
268 g
Water resistance
-
none
Foldable
-
Yes
Detachable cable
Yes
Yes
USB-C
Yes
No
Connector
USB-C
3.5 mm
Microphones
1
-
Call noise reduction
Yes
-

What reviewers said

ASTRO Gaming A50 Gen 5

This premium wireless headset is designed for gamers who want seamless switching between consoles and PCs, offering dual-source audio and a comfortable fit for long sessions. Its 24-hour battery life, low-latency connection, and robust build make it a versatile choice for multi-platform users, though it lacks active noise cancellation and advanced Bluetooth codecs.

  • Pro:Excellent multi-platform compatibility with easy switching
  • Pro:Long 24-hour battery life for extended gaming sessions
  • Pro:Comfortable over-ear design suitable for prolonged use
  • Con:No active noise cancellation for immersive isolation
  • Con:Only supports SBC codec over Bluetooth
  • Con:Relatively heavy at 363 grams

Shure Srh440a

The Shure SRH440A is a refreshed wired studio headphone that pairs a 40mm dynamic driver with a 40-ohm impedance, making it easy to drive from phones, laptops, and audio interfaces. Its tuning emphasizes present mids and controlled bass, which suits dialogue-heavy content, vocal monitoring, and general mix work. Built as a practical, closed-back tool with passive isolation and a foldable frame, it offers a neutral, no-frills option for entry-level studio use.

  • Pro:Easy to drive from most devices thanks to 40-ohm impedance
  • Pro:Clear, present midrange ideal for vocals and speech
  • Pro:Controlled low end suitable for monitoring
  • Con:Lacks wireless or ANC features
  • Con:No USB-C connectivity
  • Con:Sensitivity is modest, so may need more volume on quiet sources

Summaries are AI-condensed and paraphrased from published reviews and specs - not original hands-on testing. More on our method.

Compare something else

Swap either side out, or start again from the picker.

New comparisonASTRO Gaming A50 Gen 5Shure Srh440a