Over-Ear
ASTRO Gaming A50 (Gen 3)
82Great
$60
Full review dataASTRO Gaming A50 (Gen 3) vs Black Shark Fengming S1: which should you buy?
On aggregated review scores the ASTRO Gaming A50 (Gen 3) comes out ahead with an HearWiki score of 82. The full breakdown - sub-scores, specs and what reviewers actually said - is below.
Our pick: ASTRO Gaming A50 (Gen 3) - Great overall at around $60.
Over-Ear
Black Shark Fengming S1
68Good
$53
Full review dataScore breakdown
Each axis is a 0–10 blend of what reviewers scored, not a lab measurement.
ASTRO Gaming A50 (Gen 3)
Sound8.0
Battery7.0
Calls6.0
Value7.0
Black Shark Fengming S1
Sound6.5
Noise cancelling6.0
Battery8.5
Calls6.0
Value7.0
Specifications
| Spec | ASTRO Gaming A50 (Gen 3) | Black Shark Fengming S1 |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Over-Ear | Over-Ear |
| Price (USD) | $60 | $53 |
| HearWiki score | 82 / 100 · Great | 68 / 100 · Good |
| Released | 2017 | 2025 |
| Audio | ||
| Driver | dynamic | dynamic |
| Driver size | 40 mm | 40 mm |
| Drivers per side | 2 | 2 |
| Frequency response | 20Hz - 20,000Hz | 20 Hz - 20,000 Hz |
| Impedance | 48 Ω | - |
| Wireless | ||
| Bluetooth | - | 6 |
| Bluetooth version | none | 6.0 |
| Codecs | SBC | LDAC, LDHC, AAC |
| Multipoint pairing | No | Yes |
| Latency | - | 60 ms |
| Wireless range | 9.1 m | 10 m |
| Battery | ||
| Battery life | 15 h | 155 h |
| Battery life (ANC on) | - | 80 h |
| Full charge time | - | 132 min |
| Wireless charging | No | - |
| Features | ||
| Active noise cancelling | No | - |
| ANC type | - | adaptive |
| Transparency mode | - | Yes |
| Companion app | - | No |
| Custom EQ | - | No |
| Wear detection | - | No |
| Voice assistant | - | yes |
| Design | ||
| Weight | 380 g | - |
| Water resistance | none | yes |
| USB-C | - | Yes |
| Calls | ||
| Microphones | 1 | 5 |
| Call noise reduction | - | ANC / environmental noise cancellation |
What reviewers said
ASTRO Gaming A50 (Gen 3)
The ASTRO Gaming A50 (Gen 3) is a premium wireless headset designed for immersive gaming, delivering crisp virtual surround sound and a comfortable over-ear fit. Its standout feature is the convenient charging base, which also acts as a hub for connectivity, though the detachable microphone and software experience are less impressive than the hardware itself.
- Pro:Immersive virtual 7.1 surround sound
- Pro:Comfortable for long gaming sessions
- Pro:Convenient charging base and dock
- Con:Microphone quality is only average
- Con:Companion software is clunky
- Con:No Bluetooth or multipoint support
Black Shark Fengming S1
The Black Shark Fengming S1 is an affordable over-ear wireless headphone that combines hybrid active noise cancellation with an exceptionally long battery life of up to 155 hours without ANC and 80 hours with it engaged. It supports high-quality audio codecs like LDAC and LDHC, offers Bluetooth 6 connectivity with multipoint pairing, and includes a transparency mode, making it a versatile budget option for everyday listening.
- Pro:Exceptional battery life, especially with ANC off
- Pro:Supports high-res wireless audio via LDAC and LDHC
- Pro:Hybrid ANC with transparency mode for flexible listening
- Con:No companion app or custom EQ options
- Con:No wear detection for auto-pause
- Con:Charging takes over two hours, which is relatively slow
Summaries are AI-condensed and paraphrased from published reviews and specs - not original hands-on testing. More on our method.
Compare something else
Swap either side out, or start again from the picker.